KmikeyM covers the Econ Nobel

Rankings / Candidate

Susan C. Athey

Stanford Graduate School of Business · Market design

Photo: Christopher Michel, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Currently #2, tier Darkhorse, score 25.8, named by 5 sources.Score history: 0.0, 75.0, 51.0, 51.0, 68.6, 49.3, 49.3, 28.6, 27.2, 25.8, 25.8

The work. Athey is the economist who took auction theory and mechanism design into the machine age. Her early work on comparative statics and auctions was pure theory; then she spent years as Microsoft's chief economist and came back writing about how platforms should price, match, and learn. Along the way she became one of the leading voices on using machine learning inside causal inference, so that a policy evaluation and a recommendation engine can be built with the same tools.

The case for. She is the first woman to win the John Bates Clark Medal, the most cited living economist on the economics of technology, and Clarivate just paired her with Hal Varian under a single citation. That is the committee's favorite shape: two people, one field, one clean sentence. The digital economy has not had its Nobel yet, and it is overdue.

The case against. Her body of work is wide rather than deep on one theorem, and the committee likes a theorem. Mechanism design was rewarded in 2007 and auctions in 2020, so a third prize in the neighborhood needs a distinct story. She is also young by Nobel standards, and the committee has time.

The KmikeyM angle. KmikeyM is a platform that matches a person's decisions to a market of shareholders, which is an Athey problem stated in miniature. Her work on how platforms learn what to offer is the closest anyone has come to a theory of how a person could be run as a marketplace.

What the sources say

  1. Clarivate Citation Laureates named Susan C. Athey: for pioneering analysis of the economics of information technology (heat 100) Clarivate names four, and two of them run the internet
  2. Kalshi priced Susan C. Athey at 19%: last trade 19 cents on Sept 17, the Clarivate morning, after a 500-contract fill at 15 and a 30-contract spike to 67; resting bid 7, ask 15 (heat 19) Kalshi has been open since July, and Athey moved on Clarivate day
  3. Kalshi priced Susan C. Athey at 60%: last trade 60 cents on Sept 24, 23:45 PT, on about three contracts; earlier that day a 500-contract buy at 15; resting bid 7, ask 15 (heat 60) Two big orders two minutes apart, then a night of noise
  4. Kalshi priced Susan C. Athey at 15%: last trade 15 cents on Sept 30, 19:05 PT, one contract; sold as low as 8 on Sept 28 PT, bought back at 14 to 16 on Sept 30; resting bid 25, ask 50, one contract each side (heat 15) Pakes pulls ahead on Kalshi, and Athey's 60 unwinds
  5. Kalshi priced Susan C. Athey at 15%: last trade 15 cents on Oct 5, 02:29Z; sold to 9 on a 102-contract hit Oct 3, bought back to 15 and 16 in small lots over the weekend; resting bid 10, ask 16; second-largest open interest, 1,441 (heat 15) Pakes consolidates, and a quiet 500-lot lands on Mas-Colell
  6. Kalshi priced Susan C. Athey at 20%: last trade 20 cents on Oct 6, 20:16Z; 58 trades in a day, the busiest name on the book, bought from 19 to 26 and sold back to 20 on 150- and 80-contract hits; resting bid 18, ask 21; open interest 2,725, now the largest on the board (heat 20) Polymarket opens with seventeen names, and six new sources join the board
  7. Polymarket priced Susan C. Athey at 19%: opening day; bid 18, ask 19, last trade 18; $4,393 traded (heat 19) Polymarket opens with seventeen names, and six new sources join the board
  8. Prophet Arena AI consensus priced Susan C. Athey at 38%: consensus of 10 models; individual models ran from 20 to 47 percent (heat 38) Polymarket opens with seventeen names, and six new sources join the board
  9. Octagon AI model priced Susan C. Athey at 1%: model probability as of July 28 (heat 1) Polymarket opens with seventeen names, and six new sources join the board
  10. Kalshi priced Susan C. Athey at 16%: last trade 16 cents on Oct 9, 15:26Z; sold from 21 to 12 across 25 trades on Oct 7, then bought back through 13 and 15 on Oct 8 and 9, including a 525-contract buy at 13 and a 583-contract buy at 15; 88 trades and 5,464 contracts in three days; resting bid 14, ask 16; open interest 7,051, the largest on the book (heat 16) Three days out, Kalshi adds three names and both markets sell Athey down
  11. Polymarket priced Susan C. Athey at 14%: bid 14, ask 15, last trade 14; $9,829 traded; up 4 on the day, which means she was displayed near 10 on Thursday (heat 14) Three days out, Kalshi adds three names and both markets sell Athey down
  12. Kalshi priced Susan C. Athey at 12%: last trade 12 cents at 09:32Z; 145 trades and 7,040 contracts since Friday, almost all between 12 and 16; open interest 12,309 at settlement, the largest on the book to the end; settled no (heat 12) Hall and Woodford win. The board had Woodford third and Hall forty-fifth. Here is the scorecard.
  13. Polymarket priced Susan C. Athey at 11%: last trade 11 cents at 09:36Z; displayed 10 at 09:00Z; 80 trades and $3,123 since Friday; $15,065 for the season; settled no (heat 11) Hall and Woodford win. The board had Woodford third and Hall forty-fifth. Here is the scorecard.